The Preda Foundation has been trading with partners both
North and South in this movement since 1974. As a Southern Alternative Trading
Organization and former member of the executive Committee of the International
Association of Fair Trade (IFAT) Preda has been contributing to the concept
of Fair Trade and Alternative Trade for some time. Preda has been marketing
and exporting the products of many producer groups and supports a Grameen
Type banking system project for 240 impoverished women in Olongapo.
FAIR TRADE IS ESSENTIALLY paying a just price for products
produced under environmentally sustainable and just social conditions What
is a just price of course is relative top local conditions. However it reached
through respectful dialogue not a buyer's or seller's dictates or demands.
Both parties have a relationship based on respect, and decision making process
is influenced strongly by the manner in which they hold Human Dignity in
highest regard.
Fair trade is also a process by which producers have the
means to produce their products with a fair chance to succeed. It means
the buyer does not have the producer capitalize the entire production but
where advances are made, and payments of balances are on time. Other cooperative
actions such as design workshops, marketing strategies, packaging etc are
discussed and agreed. Fair Trade is about getting the best for the Producers
so that they can get to market and bypass loan sharks, cartels monopolies
and the absence of capital.
Fair trade is not just a relationship with a group of producers
who supply good to sale for fair prices. Fair Trade as an activity in itself
is a decisive action to uphold important ethical and moral principles and
they must be clearly and forcefully communicated to the world. Fair Trade
teaches by example - good example. It teaches all who can be reached and
will listen. Therefore it is a movement for justice and equity and human
rights. Because the rights to food, shelter and the needs of life are impossible
without a livelihood to provide them, people need the ability to produce
and prosper, it is this that will ensure their Human Rights.
Fair trade is also about UNFAIR trade. We cannot stand
by and remain silent when the poor are being mercilessly exploited, abused
and enslaved by liberal capitalism. Fair Trade organizations have a moral
obligation to campaign against unfair trade practices that are destroying
the environment or using child labor in making carpets as much as they have
to practice Fair Trade. Campaigning for Social Justice is an essential role
of an Alternative or Fair Trading Organization.
Many in the fair trade movement realize that trading honestly
and justly however good it is will not change the underlying causes of poverty.
The inequality of living standards today where a minority live in luxury
and comfort surrounded by the security of the welfare state while billions
live in hunger and want calls for action that will bring change on a global
scale. But the question is how and what to do?
The disparity between rich and poor troubles the conscience
of many to the point where they cannot enjoy their wealth and the prestige
it gives them. Many feel that they lead a privileged life but yet they are
unhappy because they know there are so many who suffer perhaps because of
the unjust trading policies of their own society. Much of their working
life contributes to that unjust system. There must be more they can do besides
talking about it.
Fair Trade for some became the answer. We may not be able
to change the unjust world, they said, but we can help a few by trading
fairly with them and restoring their pride, dignity and self-sufficiency.
Others went further and believed that while practicing FAIR TRADE THEY MUST
ALSO EDUCATE THE PUBLIC AS TO THE CONDITIONS IN THIRD WORLD COUNTRIES THAT
MUST BE CHANGED. Exactly how they can be changed is not always made clear
in the education materials. But knowing about a problem is not the same
as acting on that knowledge to change it. ATOs need to provide the issue
and the campaign as an occasion for public to actively participate. All
of us who have joined rallies or mass actions know that we are changed by
the experience.
Campaigning is a vital and important activity for a FTO/ATO
and for all to participate in. In fact without it can we really call ourselves
an Alternative Organization to the unjust system? ALTERNATIVE or FAIR TRADING
ORGANIZATIONS (ATOs / FTOs) owe their existence to the perfidy and evil
of human kind.
Greed, avarice and the desire to dominate others economically
and politically leads to unjust oppressive practices that exploit the ignorance
and poverty of the weak. This human trait has brought about a situation
where a few elite people in society control and manipulate the economic
activities of many millions of people.
Such unjust practices have been institutionalized into
a trading system that is now world wide, operating through agencies like
APEC and THE WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION. If this is evil on a grand scale
then there is a compelling challenge for the Alternative or Fair Trade Movement
to confront it anew if world poverty is to be solved. Uncontrolled Free
trade, imposed by dominating nations wipe out local and indigenous industry
and enrich the more powerful trading country all the more. The rich become
richer and the poor poorer.
The Cartels
It could be said that the World is ruled by trading cartels
rather than governments. The Transnational companies own allegiance to no
nation and no power outside themselves. Where the corporate Executive Officer
of such a company can earn a salary of over a million dollars a year and
the company can count profits in the billions then it is not surprising
that millions live in the most unspeakable poverty, ignorance and degradation
throughout the world while the elite live in unbelievable luxury. It seems
that the modern day Lazarus at the gates of the rich don't even have the
sympathy of the dogs to lick their sores - they had to eat them.
The Beginning of the ATOs
The Alternative or Fair Trade Movement set out in the early
days to confront this terrible injustice. It chose education and example
as its mode of action. Education has for the more active organizations has
taken on the campaign strategy sometimes with positive effect. Today the
campaign strategy has largely fallen by the wayside but others make use
of it with devastating effect such as Greenpeace who have forced changes
in government policy and even made corporations like Shell to change their
environmental damaging ways. All this by educating and arousing public awareness
by dramatic actions. If they can do it for the trees and the whales why
not for the impoverished starving masses who are increasing their numbers
to give themselves a better chance of survival since huge numbers of them
are killed by hunger and sickness?
Campaigning
The Fair Trade movement ought to return to the campaign
trail to confront the unjust trading cartels and systems and challenge them
to change trading attitudes from a fixation with "maximizing profits"
to a moral concern to "benefit the producers and end poverty".
It is a movement that should be exerting every effort to convince as many
as possible in the commercial world to practice just and honest trade as
the way to redress the unconscionable poverty and exploitation that causes
unbearable suffering around the world.
I believe that somehow the movement has perhaps lost it's
way a bit in this regard. Desperate to survive the heat of modern competition
from commercial companies and fake ATO's the genuine ATO's have turned to
the commercial world's management techniques to improve efficiency and we
should ask if they have been somewhat seduced by them concentrating more
on "business" and less on education, commitment and involvement
through activism and campaigning for just trading and against injustice.
Modern Managers Out of Touch With the Poor?
The modern managers of Northern ATO's may not have been
exposed to the principles, vision and mission of the ATO movement and perhaps
have never lived in a Third World Country or even visited one for any length
of time. ATOs or FTO's as some call themselves have to work within an unjust
trading system. How to do this without being corrupted by it and its practices
calls for constant vigilance and constant review of practice to determine
that the trading is not compromising the principles of fairness and justice.
Working within the system can make traders dependent on
it and thus a weakness is immediately apparent. Criticism of the existing
injustices and the political and trading structures that thrive on exploitation
of the poor can be dangerous or bad for business. However such critical
activity and consumer education and campaigning has been one of the most
important activities of the FTO movement in the past. These days there is
much too little of it to inspire a new generation of young people to selfless
giving or to counter the seduction of the materialistic world that makes
wearing the latest brand name designer jeans more important than saving
children from the slavery of the Asian carpet factories.
ATO's who have wandered from the campaign trail are slowly
dying principally because they are selling to an older generation of principled
people but not the youth of the new generation whom they have failed to
sufficiently inspire with concern for the poor. In a politically oppressed
society in the developing world an ATO could be subject to harassment, threats
and charges for criticizing exploitative practices, policies of cartels
multinationals and economic agencies. Some understandably shun such radical
activities. However in the North where there is greater freedom to speak
out more needs to be done. This was the original basis of North-South solidarity
- trading came at a later stage.
An ATO/FTO that trades justly, providing better markets
to small producer groups is still only a intermediate solution because the
scale of its operation reaches just a few of the many millions who live
in wretched conditions, bonded and exploited. Constant effort and activism
is needed to address the root causes. Such development education through
campaigns for the youth is needed as much in the South as in the North.
Without action programmes are ATOs really Alternative to anything? Or just
a commercial enterprise with a charitable point of view? Besides looking
at the immediate terms of the trade such as prices paid, and benefits shared,
services rendered, levels of self-reliance self-esteem and prosperity reached
an evaluation of an FTO/ATO must consider the contribution of the FTO/ATO
to challenging society and working to change the selfish attitude that permits
exploitation and allows world wide inequalities between rich and poor.
Alternative Tourism as an Educational Experience
One practical way of developing commitment and understanding
is exposure visits by Northern people to producers in the South through
alternative Tourism. Meeting the poor of the South is a sure form of education
that cannot be equalled. Preda presently hosts many such groups every year
from Japan, Germany and other European countries. Many of our visitors are
now involved in campaigns to stop exploitation of children in the labor
force and to make the world of trading a more just and fair relationship. |